9 Top-Rated Beaches in Key West, FL · 1. Smathers Beach · 2. South Beach · 3. Higgs Beach · 4. Simonton Beach · 5. Fort Zachary Taylor Beach · 6. 1) Dry Tortugas & Fort Jefferson To many, this secluded cluster of islands 70 miles west of Key West is home to the most beautiful beach in the Florida Keys. · 2. Key West's largest beach has all the ingredients for a golden tan: picture-perfect stretch of sand, chair rentals, volleyball courts and a calm breeze. Located. Beaches in Key West · 1. Fort Zachary Taylor Historic State Park · 2. Smathers Beach · 3. Higgs Beach · 4. South Beach · 5. Simonton Street Beach · 6. Dog Beach. 3. Rest Beach · 4. Clarence S. Higgs Memorial Beach Park · 5. Fort Zachary Taylor Beach · 6. South Beach · 7. Sunset Key · 8. Casa Marina Resort And. Looking for a good beach while visiting Key West? Many visitors are surprised to find that the island paradise of the Florida Keys does not have a lot of. By far the most popular beach on the island, Smathers Beach is the place to go for all-day action. Stretching about two miles down Roosevelt. A Guide to Some of the Best Public Beaches in the Florida Keys and Key West · John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park · Harry Harris Beach and Park. There are five different public beaches situated on the southeastern side of Key West. This guide provides an overview of these popular stretches of sand. Key West beaches provide a wonderful opportunity to experience first-hand Caribbean style coral reef beaches. This is because Key West and the Florida Keys.